20100404031151A

Accident · Substantial damage

FAA accident report · Piper PA-31-350 · Honolulu, HI · April 4, 2010

Date
April 4, 2010 · 10:38 local
Place
Honolulu, HI
Airport
Honolulu
Phase of flight
Taxi
Operating rules
Air taxi and commuter (Part 135)
Operator
QF0A
Collision
Collision on the ground
Damage
Substantial damage
Aircraft
N61384
NTSB investigation
NTSBWPR10LA189
Reported as
Piper PA-31-350
Reported engine
Lycoming TI0-540 series
People aboard
1
Fatal injuries
0
Other injuries
0
Pilot’s certificates
Airline transport, commercial pilot
Pilot’s flight hours
16,000 total10,000 in this make and model10 in the last 90 days

From the FAA’s Accident/Incident Data System (AIDS), through its Aviation Safety Information Portal, as reported. The NTSB investigates accidents separately, and its record of an accident is the fuller one. The aircraft is matched to the registry by N-number and event date, checked against the reported make and model; the registry’s history has gaps, so older matches can be wrong. Compare the reported make and model.

What happened

The FAA’s narrative, in sentence case. The FAA writes it in capitals and removes private details.

Sunday 4-4-2010 13:11 notified to investigate an aircraft accident on Honolulu airfield. N61384, PA31, pacific air charters, refueled, returned to ramp to board pax and taxied into N1149Y, C150, an unoccupied parked aircraft at 042130 UTC - this info based on the ATC 8020-9 that was submitted. 13:41 arrived at FSDO. 14:06 on scene south ramp accident site with insp johnson and lee. Pilot of PA31 was guy davis(gd). He had left the scene unable to locate him. I4:14 interviewed privacy data omitted, a pilot and eyewitness to the accident. He was walking nearby and observed the PA31 taxi into the Cessna. He approached the aircraft, checked for fuel leaks, checked aircraft, and secured the site. He indicated he had talked to gd - gave him a ride to air service. privacy data omitted Will provide a written statement to me for the investigation. 14:25 viewed video footage of security cameras of accident at george's aviation. Video showed PA31 collide with the Cessna at 1038 local time. George's will attempt to download footage file for forwarding to the FSDO. 15:15 back to office to research gd. Called rob moore (rm), privacy data omitted, director ops for pacific air charters. He indicated he was busy trying to move the PA31 and was too busy to talk. Said to call him back and leave a message with FSDO office phone number for gd to call tomorrow. Called back and left message. 16:15 secured from investigation for the day. Numerous attempts all week to reach pilot guy davis. Finally spoke to him and requested an office visit to obtain details of accident. Interviewed davis thurs 8 apr 13:32. Only documents he presented were his medical certificate and pilot certificate. Did not want to make a statement as the company would provide statement. Friday 9 April 2010 - rob moore, chief pilot, hand delivered copy of NTSB report he submitted. Called privacy data omitted - asked him if it was raining when he witnessed the accident. He told me that it was not raining. Will follow up with an email to include 12:25 rob moore called - he has finished NTSB report. Considering I have no other information from him I said I did want a copy. He is to stop by and hand deliver a copy. 12:45 inspector carol perry^ (cp) the poi for tropic air charters was called by rob moore to tell her the company was involved in an accident last Sunday. He noted that he still thought it was not an accident. He asked cp if she wanted a copy of the NTSB report - she responded she did not want one - work with the accident team investigators. Monday 4-12-2010 went to accident site to take more photos of skid marks and make some more measurements. Tuesday 4-13-2010REVISED letter to guy davis, request for accident documentation. Cced patrick mcnamee, and rob moore. Friday 4-16-2010 called by patrick mcnamee (pres for pacific air charters) c 284-0324 to inquire about letter that was sent to gd. Informed him we need information to close out accident report. Set up meeting at 1400 Monday 19 April to discuss details of accident. Monday 4-19-2010 1400 meeting with guy davis, rob moore, and darett kanayama assisted me with the interview. Attendees provided some of the required information about the accident. Major discussion whether it was an accident or incident. Guy davis stated a wind anomaly and wet surface area caused the accident. He could not recall what he was doing in the cockpit just prior to impact with the Cessna 150. Trip logs for guy davis were provided. He did not bring his training records. Rob moore will deliver requested documents.

As the FAA filed it

SUNDAY 4-4-2010 13:11 NOTIFIED TO INVESTIGATE AN AIRCRAFT ACCIDENT ON HONOLULU AIRFIELD. N61384, PA31, PACIFIC AIR CHARTERS, REFUELED, RETURNED TO RAMP TO BOARD PAX AND TAXIED INTO N1149Y, C150, AN UNOCCUPIED PARKED AIRCRAFT AT 042130 UTC - THIS INFO BASED ON THE ATC 8020-9 THAT WAS SUBMITTED. 13:41 ARRIVED AT FSDO. 14:06 ON SCENE SOUTH RAMP ACCIDENT SITE WITH INSP JOHNSON AND LEE. PILOT OF PA31 WAS GUY DAVIS(GD). HE HAD LEFT THE SCENE UNABLE TO LOCATE HIM. I4:14 INTERVIEWED ^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^, A PILOT AND EYEWITNESS TO THE ACCIDENT. HE WAS WALKING NEARBY AND OBSERVED THE PA31 TAXI INTO THE CESSNA. HE APPROACHED THE AIRCRAFT, CHECKED FOR FUEL LEAKS, CHECKED AIRCRAFT, AND SECURED THE SITE. HE INDICATED HE HAD TALKED TO GD - GAVE HIM A RIDE TO AIR SERVICE. ^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^ WILL PROVIDE A WRITTEN STATEMENT TO ME FOR THE INVESTIGATION. 14:25 VIEWED VIDEO FOOTAGE OF SECURITY CAMERAS OF ACCIDENT AT GEORGE'S AVIATION. VIDEO SHOWED PA31 COLLIDE WITH THE CESSNA AT 1038 LOCAL TIME. GEORGE'S WILL ATTEMPT TO DOWNLOAD FOOTAGE FILE FOR FORWARDING TO THE FSDO. 15:15 BACK TO OFFICE TO RESEARCH GD. CALLED ROB MOORE (RM), ^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^, DIRECTOR OPS FOR PACIFIC AIR CHARTERS. HE INDICATED HE WAS BUSY TRYING TO MOVE THE PA31 AND WAS TOO BUSY TO TALK. SAID TO CALL HIM BACK AND LEAVE A MESSAGE WITH FSDO OFFICE PHONE NUMBER FOR GD TO CALL TOMORROW. CALLED BACK AND LEFT MESSAGE. 16:15 SECURED FROM INVESTIGATION FOR THE DAY. NUMEROUS ATTEMPTS ALL WEEK TO REACH PILOT GUY DAVIS. FINALLY SPOKE TO HIM AND REQUESTED AN OFFICE VISIT TO OBTAIN DETAILS OF ACCIDENT. INTERVIEWED DAVIS THURS 8 APR 13:32. ONLY DOCUMENTS HE PRESENTED WERE HIS MEDICAL CERTIFICATE AND PILOT CERTIFICATE. DID NOT WANT TO MAKE A STATEMENT AS THE COMPANY WOULD PROVIDE STATEMENT. FRIDAY 9 APRIL 2010 - ROB MOORE, CHIEF PILOT, HAND DELIVERED COPY OF NTSB REPORT HE SUBMITTED. CALLED ^PRIVACY DATA OMITTED^ - ASKED HIM IF IT WAS RAINING WHEN HE WITNESSED THE ACCIDENT. HE TOLD ME THAT IT WAS NOT RAINING. WILL FOLLOW UP WITH AN EMAIL TO INCLUDE 12:25 ROB MOORE CALLED - HE HAS FINISHED NTSB REPORT. CONSIDERING I HAVE NO OTHER INFORMATION FROM HIM I SAID I DID WANT A COPY. HE IS TO STOP BY AND HAND DELIVER A COPY. 12:45 INSPECTOR CAROL PERRY^ (CP) THE POI FOR TROPIC AIR CHARTERS WAS CALLED BY ROB MOORE TO TELL HER THE COMPANY WAS INVOLVED IN AN ACCIDENT LAST SUNDAY. HE NOTED THAT HE STILL THOUGHT IT WAS NOT AN ACCIDENT. HE ASKED CP IF SHE WANTED A COPY OF THE NTSB REPORT - SHE RESPONDED SHE DID NOT WANT ONE - WORK WITH THE ACCIDENT TEAM INVESTIGATORS. MONDAY 4-12-2010 WENT TO ACCIDENT SITE TO TAKE MORE PHOTOS OF SKID MARKS AND MAKE SOME MORE MEASUREMENTS. TUESDAY 4-13-2010REVISED LETTER TO GUY DAVIS, REQUEST FOR ACCIDENT DOCUMENTATION. CCED PATRICK MCNAMEE, AND ROB MOORE. FRIDAY 4-16-2010 CALLED BY PATRICK MCNAMEE (PRES FOR PACIFIC AIR CHARTERS) C 284-0324 TO INQUIRE ABOUT LETTER THAT WAS SENT TO GD. INFORMED HIM WE NEED INFORMATION TO CLOSE OUT ACCIDENT REPORT. SET UP MEETING AT 1400 MONDAY 19 APRIL TO DISCUSS DETAILS OF ACCIDENT. MONDAY 4-19-2010 1400 MEETING WITH GUY DAVIS, ROB MOORE, AND DARETT KANAYAMA ASSISTED ME WITH THE INTERVIEW. ATTENDEES PROVIDED SOME OF THE REQUIRED INFORMATION ABOUT THE ACCIDENT. MAJOR DISCUSSION WHETHER IT WAS AN ACCIDENT OR INCIDENT. GUY DAVIS STATED A WIND ANOMALY AND WET SURFACE AREA CAUSED THE ACCIDENT. HE COULD NOT RECALL WHAT HE WAS DOING IN THE COCKPIT JUST PRIOR TO IMPACT WITH THE CESSNA 150. TRIP LOGS FOR GUY DAVIS WERE PROVIDED. HE DID NOT BRING HIS TRAINING RECORDS. ROB MOORE WILL DELIVER REQUESTED DOCUMENTS.

NTSB investigation

The NTSB’s investigation of this event, with its probable cause and findings. Matched to this report by N-number and date.

Other reports on N61384 · 2

Matched to the same aircraft by N-number and date.